How Many Stamps Should a Coffee Shop Card Have
Don't pick a number. Pick how long a regular should wait for the free drink, then count backwards. Someone who stops in five days a week fills a 10-stamp card in two weeks. Someone who only comes on Saturdays takes ten. Rambla's starting cards are 10 stamps for a coffee shop and 8 for a bakery, and both are yours to change.
By The Rambla team, last changed , reviewed
Count backwards from the wait
A regular who keeps coming at the same pace fills the card in stamps divided by visits a week. That's the wait. Here it is for three card lengths and four kinds of regular.
| How often they visit | 8 stamps | 10 stamps | 12 stamps |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 visits a week | 1.6 weeks | 2 weeks | 2.4 weeks |
| 3 visits a week | 2.7 weeks | 3.3 weeks | 4 weeks |
| 1 visit a week | 8 weeks | 10 weeks | 12 weeks |
| 1 visit every 2 weeks | 16 weeks | 20 weeks | 24 weeks |
Read down the 10-stamp column. The same card is a two-week goal for your weekday regulars and a ten-week one for the person who treats themselves on Saturdays. Neither is wrong, but only one of them is likely to still be excited by week eight.
Try a few lengths
What people have found about cards like this
On a buy-ten-get-one coffee card, people bought coffee about 20% more often as they got closer to the free one, then slowed back down after redeeming it. That's Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng, in the Journal of Marketing Research in 2006.
A different 2006 paper, by Nunes and Drèze in the Journal of Consumer Research, reports that turning an eight-step task into a ten-step task with two steps already done makes people more likely to finish it, and quicker to finish.
Neither paper tells you how many stamps your shop needs. What they suggest is something about people: we speed up when the finish line is close, and a head start makes it feel closer. Rambla's starting cards give a free cookie with the first stamp. That isn't a pre-stamped card, but we think it does some of the same work, because the first visit counts for something.
Longer cards cost less per stamp
The same reward spread over more spending costs a smaller share of it. Take the free drink from the reward cost guide, $1.50 to make with a $6 average stamped visit:
| Stamps for a reward | Cost as a share of spending |
|---|---|
| 8 | 3.1% |
| 10 | 2.5% |
| 12 | 2.1% |
What earns a stamp
On Rambla a stamp can count a visit, a purchase or one specific item, like a latte. If your regulars sometimes come in twice a day, counting visits will fill the card faster than you meant, so a rule that counts purchases or items may fit better.
Our advice
Choose the wait first, then the stamps that match your regulars' usual visits. After a month, look at how many people reached the reward. If hardly anyone did, shorten the card.
A note on the evidence
The tables are division. Two published studies are cited below, and both are about how people behave on loyalty cards in general, not about your shop. We don't give a benchmark for the right number of stamps, because we don't have data that would support one.
Sources
- On a buy-ten-get-one coffee card, people bought coffee about 20% more often as they got closer to the free one: Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng, Journal of Marketing Research, 2006, checked
- Turning an eight-step task into a ten-step task with two steps already complete increases the likelihood of completion and decreases completion time: Nunes and Drèze, The Endowed Progress Effect, Journal of Consumer Research 32(4), 2006, checked
Quick questions
Is 10 stamps too many for a coffee shop?
Not if your regulars come in most days. At 5 visits a week a 10-stamp card takes 2 weeks. At 1 visit a week it takes 10, and a shorter card would suit those customers better.
Can a stamp count one item instead of a visit?
Yes. A stamp can count a visit, a purchase or a specific item, like one stamp per latte.
How long should a card take to finish?
We don't have a number that holds for every shop. Choose the wait you want for your regulars at their usual pace, then check how many finish the card and adjust.