Guide

What a Free Drink Really Costs Your Coffee Shop

A free drink is a smaller number than it feels like. Say it costs $1.50 to make and your regulars average $6 a visit. On a 10-stamp card, the reward hands back 2.5% of what they spend to earn it, or 8.3% if you count the drink at its $5 menu price. Those numbers are made up. The calculator below takes yours.

By The Rambla team, last changed , reviewed

Start with the drink, not the program

Handing over a free latte feels like handing over five dollars. It isn't. You hand over a cup, a shot, some milk and about a minute of somebody's time. Five dollars is what the menu says, and what you give up is what it costs you to make.

So the question isn't whether you can afford a reward. It's how much of your customers' spending the reward gives back, and that's one line of division: what the reward costs you, over the stamps it takes times what a regular spends on a visit that earns a stamp.

Little Cup Cafe, with invented numbers

Little Cup Cafe isn't a real place, and neither are its numbers. Swap in yours as you read.

Little Cup Cafe, an example
InputValue
Free drink, cost to make$1.50
Free drink, menu price$5.00
Stamps for a reward10
Average spend on a stamped visit$6.00
Spending to earn one reward$60.00
Reward cost share at cost2.5%
Reward cost share at menu price8.3%

Your turn

Reward cost share at cost2.5% of what they spend
Reward cost share at menu price8.3% of what they spend
This counts only the reward. It leaves out the fee for your card, staff time and any extra visits the card brings

Two ways to count it

The cost number is the honest one for your books. The menu price number is the one your customer sees. If you aren't sure what a drink really costs you, we'd plan around the menu price: if your true cost is lower, you get a pleasant surprise instead of an unpleasant one.

What this number doesn't know about

  • The monthly fee for whatever runs the card
  • Staff time at the counter
  • Regulars who would have come in anyway
  • Extra visits the card might bring, which we don't try to guess
  • Cards that never get finished, which make the real cost lower

This isn't a sales forecast

The calculator tells you what giving the reward costs. Whether a card brings people back more often is a different question, and the way to answer it is to compare how often your regulars visit before and after you start.

Where these numbers come from

Nothing here is measured. The formula is division, the example is invented, and we cite no outside study because none was needed. The calculator does the same arithmetic in your browser and keeps what you type to itself.

Questions we get

Should I count the reward at cost or at menu price?

Work out both. Cost is what you actually give up, and menu price is what the customer sees. If you're unsure of your costs, plan around the higher number.

Does this include the software fee?

No, only the reward. Add whatever you pay to run the card. Rewards is $30 per month for each storefront, after a 60-day free trial. Your customers never pay anything.

What if people don't finish the card?

Then the reward costs you less than the figure shown. The calculator assumes every stamp comes from a visit at the average spend and that the card gets finished.

More guides

Set up your card and keep the cost in view

Start Free Trial